
Freight rail operator BNSF filed its opposition to the proposed Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern merger with the Surface Transportation Board on November 18. The filing includes a brief supported by more than 130 exhibits, declarations from BNSF executives and expert witnesses, and extensive supporting data.
BNSF’s public summary of the evidence outlines why it believes the merger would harm competition, raise costs for shippers, and fail to deliver its promised benefits.
“UP will be UP — with more market power,” the brief argues.
Read More: STB Rejects Petitions to Deny UP/Norfolk Merger Proposal
An earlier filing to the STB on September 9 outlined the conditions BNSF would seek to protect competition if the merger is approved, while November 18's filing formally presents BNSF's opposition to the merger, backed by extensive evidence, expert testimony, and analysis.
The more recent filing builds on BNSF's previously stated concerns and provides a more detailed case for why the merger is not in the public interest.
Among other complaints, BNSF says there are questionable traffic projections for the merger. BNSF identifies more than 310 errors and corrections in UP/NS’s traffic analysis, calling into question its projected truck-to-rail traffic gains. Another issue is limited shipper protections. BNSF argues that UP/NS’s proposed Committed Gateway Pricing program would cover just 0.9% of rail traffic.
BNSF also points to broad opposition. “Shipper groups representing more than 50% of rail cargo have opposed or raised concerns about the merger, while unions representing more than 70% of the projected combined unionized workforce oppose it,” the filing said.
Read More: Farmers Union Pushes Back Against Proposed Rail Mega-Merger
BNSF is one of six major Class I freight railroads (companies with annual operating revenues exceeding $1 billion) serving the U.S. market. The others are BNSF Railway, CSX Transportation, Canadian National Railway (CN), and CPKC Railway (Canadian Pacific Kansas City).


















