Are Critical Industrial Metals in for a Decade-Long Price Rise? | SupplyChainBrain

Are Critical Industrial Metals in for a Decade-Long Price Rise?

Periodic table of elements with Chinese and American flags overlaid, representing international chemistry or science collaboration
iStock/William_Potter

In 1980, economist Julian Simon and biologist Paul Ehrlich made a bet. Addressing concerns over a growing scarcity of natural resources, Simon predicted that the prices of a select group of raw materials — copper, chromium, nickel, tin and tungsten — would not rise over the next decade. Ehrlich said they would. The two men wagered $10,000. Simon won.

The now-famous Simon-Ehrlich wager has often been cited as a counter to alarmists who foretell shrinking supplies and soaring prices of commodities that are essential to the production of everything from defense systems to cell phones. Now, with wars waging, geopolitical pressures intensifying and high-tech products more critical to societies than ever before, dire predictions about material cost and availability are once more on the rise. But are they justifiable this time around?

Take the question of industrial metals pricing. A new report from trade credit insurance provider Coface finds that the price of copper and nickel could double over the next decade, with demand far outpacing supply. Drawing on data from the London Metal Exchange, U.S. Geological Survey, World Bank and International Energy Agency, the report projects "a sustained period of higher costs," driven in large part by electrification and clean energy projects. Factors dampening the supply to meet that demand include a sharp increase in trade barriers, long timelines for developing new mines, and China's continued dominance over refining capacity for key minerals.

Copper supplies could fall short by as much as 17%, the report says, leading to a deficit of 1.5 million to  6.5 million tons by 2035 — fulfilling just 11% of projected demand. Nickel might be in for an even worse scenario, facing "the largest imbalance of any metal studied." For that category, Coface sees a possible supply deficit of 35%, driven by increases in battery manufacturing.

Aluminum confronts the prospect of a supply shortfall of 5 million to 15 million tons, due to anticipated limits on low-cost electricity and smelting capacity. the report says.

Constraints on mining capacity represent the biggest immediate risk factor in the future of industrial metals production, says Simon Lacoume, author of the Coface report. Longer term, the trend will be driven by expanding electrical grids and the construction of massive data centers supporting artificial intelligence. In the case of the latter, he says, "digital-related development is the biggest game-changer that nobody has seen coming in the past few years."

On the mining side, questions persist about the capability of Chile, Peru and the Democratic Republic of the Congo — all major sources of copper — to maintain adequate supply levels over the coming decade. And when it comes to metals refining, Coface notes, China possesses around 70% of the global capacity for 19 of 20 key minerals, while producing more than half the world's steel, aluminum and refined copper.

The big question hanging over copper in the past year has been whether the metal in its processed state will be subject to U.S. tariffs imposed by the Trump administration. Last summer, Semi-finished copper products got hit with a 50% ad valorem tariff under section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962. The status of refined copper is still under review. According to Lacoume, the situation has led to the stockpiling of some 1 million metric tons of copper in the U.S. — a so-called "copper mountain." And even if Trump declines to follow through on imposing a 15% tariff on refined copper on January 1, 2027, rising to 30% the following year, he could "keep alive the threat to do so in the future." What that's likely to do is keep the American copper stockpile high for an indefinite period.

While the near-term fate of industrial metals remains a matter of speculation, Lacoume says he's "pretty certain" that copper, at least, is in for a big price hike, as supplies of copper ore at major mines decline. "The pressure on supply and mining is real on copper," he says.

The value of nickel, over which Indonesia asserts a production monopoly, depends on how the country balances the need to meet global demand with the desire to cap supply to gin up market prices, Lacoume says.

Even a bursting of the AI investment bubble, resulting in a huge excess of data-center capacity, wouldn't necessarily drive down demand for copper and other metals to the point where global prices would fall, says Marcos Carias, North America economist with Coface. Geopolitical fragmentation, rising defense expenditures and other types of industrial investment will continue to keep demand high, and supply begging.

Some of that pricing pressure could be relieved by the creation of new supply sources, but it takes 15 to 20 years to get a new mine up and running, Carias notes. And, according to Coface, fewer than 1% of exploration projects become working mines.

"For manufacturers in the U.S. Canada and Mexico," Carias says, "that means planning for higher metal costs over the long term, instead of waiting for a trade deal to bring prices back down."

Anyone willing to take Julian Simon's side of the bet today?

Related Content

Related Videos

Featured Product

Page 1 of 27
Next Page

Visit Our Sponsors