• Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Supplier Directory
  • SCB YouTube
  • Login
  • Subscribe
  • Logout
  • My Profile
  • LOGISTICS
    • Air Cargo
    • All Logistics
    • Express/Small Shipments
    • Facility Location Planning
    • Freight Forwarding/Customs Brokerage
    • Global Gateways
    • Global Logistics
    • Last Mile Delivery
    • Logistics Outsourcing
    • LTL/Truckload Services
    • Ocean Transportation
    • Rail & Intermodal
    • Reverse Logistics
    • Service Parts Management
    • Transportation & Distribution
  • TECHNOLOGY
    • All Technology
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Cloud & On-Demand Systems
    • Data Management (Big Data/IoT/Blockchain)
    • ERP & Enterprise Systems
    • Forecasting & Demand Planning
    • Global Trade Management
    • Inventory Planning/ Optimization
    • Product Lifecycle Management
    • Sales & Operations Planning
    • SC Finance & Revenue Management
    • SC Planning & Optimization
    • Sourcing/Procurement/SRM
    • Supply Chain Visibility
    • Transportation Management
  • GENERAL SCM
    • Business Strategy Alignment
    • Education & Professional Development
    • Global Supply Chain Management
    • Global Trade & Economics
    • HR & Labor Management
    • Quality & Metrics
    • Regulation & Compliance
    • SC Security & Risk Mgmt
    • Supply Chains in Crisis
    • Sustainability & Corporate Social Responsibility
  • WAREHOUSING
    • All Warehouse Services
    • Conveyors & Sortation
    • Lift Trucks & AGVs
    • Order Fulfillment
    • Packaging
    • RFID, Barcode, Mobility & Voice
    • Robotics
    • Warehouse Management Systems
  • INDUSTRIES
    • Aerospace & Defense
    • Apparel
    • Automotive
    • Chemicals & Energy
    • Consumer Packaged Goods
    • E-Commerce/Omni-Channel
    • Food & Beverage
    • Healthcare
    • High-Tech/Electronics
    • Industrial Manufacturing
    • Pharmaceutical/Biotech
    • Retail
  • THINK TANK
  • WEBINARS
    • On-Demand Webinars
    • Upcoming Webinars
    • Webinar Library
  • PODCASTS
  • VIDEOS
  • WHITEPAPERS
Home » Could Omnichannel Become a Sustainability (and Profit) Hero?

Could Omnichannel Become a Sustainability (and Profit) Hero?

May 12, 2022
Bill Loftis, SupplyChainBrain Contributor

The key question of whether e-commerce is more or less sustainable than traditional retailing is particularly difficult to answer, because it compares visible with invisible waste.  

Visible waste is easily seen in excessive packaging and the inevitable emissions from delivery trucks. Invisible waste from car emissions when we drive to the store is generally taken for granted.

Reports suggest that our store trips are unsustainable, and often retail’s greatest emissions generator. They reason that multiple consumer store trips are less efficient than multi-stop delivery routes. As a result, reports typically lean toward e-commerce being the more sustainable option. That said, they also agree that packaging waste and delivery emissions are the most unsustainable elements of e-commerce, while noting that varying consumer habits can easily tip the balance.

A couple of e-commerce uncertainties weigh heavily in this determination: returns and order size. E-commerce returns vary widely, averaging between 20% and 40% of total volumes, and appear to be increasing. Each return is an additional shipment and often generates product waste, because many returns end up in the dump. Order size data is less clear, but e-commerce order baskets tend to be smaller than store baskets. Single-item orders aren’t penalized when shipping is “free,” but driving to the store costs time and money, so we commonly bunch items together. Therefore, what we buy on a store trip might represent multiple e-commerce shipments. Returns and order size are high multipliers to e-commerce’s sustainability impact, but less emission-sensitive with store shopping. These will tip the balance much further.

An interesting conclusion from research reports is that retail’s carbon footprint is largely dictated by consumer behavior.

Returns and small order sizes have an outsized effect on contribution margin as well. A recent CNBC article claimed that returns increased 60% last year, and cost over $760 billion. Small order sizes tremendously impact fulfillment cost as a percent of sales, also reducing margin.

But e-commerce costs are daunting by themselves, regardless of returns and order size. Direct-to-consumer fulfillment adds two expensive costs to the retailer that store shoppers handle for free: selecting the product from the shelf and bringing it home. For a business with razor-thin margins (brick and mortar retail averages about 3% net profit), a retailer absorbs handling, packaging and delivery costs, easily an additional $8-$12 per package. Instead of making $3 by selling a $100 item, with e-commerce they lose between $5 and $9. Losses gets worse as average order value drops, because package costs are relatively constant.

The strategic response has been to right-size and re-purpose stores, as seen in a raft of store closings in recent years. What we’re seeing in the e-commerce evolution is the transformation of retail stores into a hybrid mix of new store formats, urban warehouses and delivery trucks, all key building blocks of omnichannel commerce.

Using GHG Data

Innovative omnichannel strategies may be able to overcome e-commerce’s sustainability and profitability challenges by using greenhouse gas (GHG) data to influence shopping behavior.

Omnichannel retailers have the ability to influence how consumers shop through their online connection. We’ve seen constant experiments to attract customers, with options involving time, choice, price, delivery, pick-up and assistance. Why not display and compare GHG data for various order options? By showing options on timing and delivery, for example, data-savvy retailers could display comparative GHG data for different ordering scenarios, such as: 

  • Is it more sustainable to buy and pick up from a local store, or deliver from a remote location?
  • What’s the GHG impact of waiting for an item to consolidate and shipping in one package, versus backordering and shipping two?
  • What’s the emissions impact of expediting delivery for next-day (air) vs. waiting for two-day (ground) delivery? 

An infinite number of possibilities could spring from this to drive more sustainable shopping behavior. This concept essentially optimizes how consumers currently shop. But what about better ways to shop? What about omnichannel solutions that optimize sustainability?

The Subscription Solution

Consider a solution that displays GHG data and includes a regular subscription service, enabling consumers to proactively plan shopping needs, replacing frequent store trips and small one-off online orders. 

How many times per week does a household drive to the store — 10, 15, 20? A regular weekly service offering a variety of merchandise and a convenient, intelligent ordering platform could cut out many of those trips. It could source from nearby locations (whether stores or “dark” hubs), and, given time in the order cycle, use the location as a cross-dock to bundle merchandise from remote locations. To eliminate disposable packaging, it could incorporate a closed-loop return system, allowing the introduction of re-usable packaging.

A regular service could be a significant time-saver. Relative to the previous concept, GHG data could be displayed for these orders and be compared to their normal behavior (such as saving x number of trips per week).

Many possibilities could be designed around these concepts. Elements of the sustainability “secret sauce” include: 

  • Emissions information as a consumer ordering factor, like cost and time.
  • An intelligent, convenient front end, to help consumers plan and convert their shopping needs into regular large deliveries.
  • A closed-loop delivery system for re-usable packages. 

For profitability, larger bundled orders increase revenue per order and fulfillment cost as a percent of sales is reduced. Re-usable packaging is yet another cost advantage.

Omnichannel is racing ahead, resulting in the following present or emerging trends:

  • E-commerce subscription services are utilized as growth engines for selected product categories, so the subscription model is clearly around. Subscription across merchandise categories seems new.
  • Emissions data is becoming more pervasive. Carbon footprint labels on products have arrived. Labeling the order path seems new.
  • In March, 2022, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission proposed that public companies be required to disclose their own direct (Scope 1) and indirect (Scope 2) greenhouse gas emissions, as well as from their suppliers and partners (Scope 3), if they’re material or included in company-set emissions targets. Emissions disclosure is going mainstream.
  • Re-usable packaging is emerging as a desirable option in closed loop systems. This is much more advanced in Europe, but applications are being greeted in the U.S. with increased acceptance and economy. The biggest need for scalable re-usable packaging is designing circular systems, which this concept is based on.
  • A major retailer recently expanded an “in-home delivery service,” delivering into the home and filling the refrigerator. Although not a regular service, front-end consumer planning assistance must be part of it.

Will consumers buy into this? They might. Late last year, Forbes reported on a Forrester consumer interest survey with notable results:

  • 40% of U.S. online consumers prefer to buy sustainable products.
  • Around 33% of U.S. online consumers express a willingness to pay more for sustainable or environmentally friendly products.

Given that consumer preference drives omnichannel design, this is particularly encouraging. 

It seems likely that in some cases, sustainability should be an omnichannel design objective. Could these and other concepts de-carbonize shopping? Maybe. The big winner is the climate, but others are retailers (more profit) and consumers (more time). We’re already seeing parts of it, and even better, surveys indicate consumers might be delighted. We look forward to further investigation and pilots. Why not?

Bill Loftis is owner and principal of Supply Chain Ecology.

Read more of SupplyChainBrain's 2022 Supply Chain ESG Guide here.

RELATED CONTENT

RELATED VIDEOS

Sustainability & Corporate Social Responsibility E-Commerce/Omni-Channel Retail
Bill Loftis, SupplyChainBrain Contributor

More from this author

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter!

Timely, incisive articles delivered directly to your inbox.

Popular Stories

  • karen-jones.jpg

    Watch: Four Industry Disrupters Impacting Logistics

    Data Management (Big Data/IoT/Blockchain)
  • THE SPACE AROUND A COMPUTER KEYBOARD IS CLUSTERED WITH IMAGES GENERIC SHIPPING BOXES

    How Suppliers Can Overcome E-Commerce Supply Chain Challenges

    Data Management (Big Data/IoT/Blockchain)
  • A CSX TRAIN IS SEEN FROM THE FRONT

    CSX’s New CEO Has a Big Idea for Railroads: Carry More Freight

    Rail & Intermodal
  • A SEATED PERSON HOLDS A SMARTPHONE, SHOPPING

    Retail Consumer Data: The Key to Personalization, or Privacy Violation?

    Regulation & Compliance
  • A ROBOT ARM AND A HUMAN ARM ALMOST TOUCH FINGERS

    AI + SCM: A Formula for Automation and Optimization

    Supply Chain Planning & Optimization

Digital Edition

Scb q1 2023 cover

2023 Supply Chain Management Resource Guide: Packing for a Difficult Year

VIEW THE LATEST ISSUE

Case Studies

  • New Revenue for Cloud-Based TMS that Embeds Orderful’s Modern EDI Platform

  • Convenience Store Client Maximizes Profit and Improves Customer Service

  • A Digitally Native Footwear Brand Finds Rapid Fulfillment

  • Expanding Apparel Brand Scales Seamlessly with E-Commerce Technology

  • How a Global LSP Scaled its Security Program and Won More Business

Visit Our Sponsors

Orderful Yang Ming Alithya
Barcoding Blue Yonder BNSF Logistics
CoEnterprise Data Capture Deposco
E2open GAINSystems Generix
Geodis GEP GreyOrange
Here Holman Logistics Honeywell Intelligrated
IFM Infor Inmar
Keelvar Kinaxis Korber
Lean Solutions Group 2H Liberty SBF Locus Robotics
Logility LogistiVIEW Lucas Systems
MCA Connect MPO Nvidia
Old Dominion OpenText ORTEC
Overhaul Parsyl PMMI
QIMA Redwood Logistics Ryder E-commerce by Whiplash
Saddle Creek Logistics Schneider Dedicated Setlog Holding AG
Ship4WD Shipwell Shyft
Sourcemap Tecsys TGW Systems
Thomson Reuters Tive Trailer Bridge
Vecna Robotics Verity
Verusen
  • More From SCB
    • Featured Content
    • Video Library
    • Think Tank Blog
    • SupplyChainBrain Podcast
    • Whitepapers
    • On-Demand Webinars
    • Upcoming Webinars
  • Digital Offerings
    • Digital Issue
    • Subscribe
    • Manage Your Subscription
    • Newsletters
  • Resources
    • Events Calendar
    • SCB's Great Supply Chain Partners
    • Supplier Directory
    • Case Study Showcase
    • Supply Chain Innovation Awards
    • 100 Great Partners Form
  • SCB Corporate
    • Advertise on SCB.COM
    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact Us
    • Data Sharing Opt-Out

All content copyright ©2023 Keller International Publishing Corp All rights reserved. No reproduction, transmission or display is permitted without the written permissions of Keller International Publishing Corp

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing