• Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Supplier Directory
  • Login
  • Subscribe
  • Logout
  • My Profile

  • CORONAVIRUS
  • LOGISTICS
    • Air Cargo
    • All Logistics
    • Express/Small Shipments
    • Facility Location Planning
    • Freight Forwarding/Customs Brokerage
    • Global Gateways
    • Global Logistics
    • Last Mile Delivery
    • Logistics Outsourcing
    • LTL/Truckload Services
    • Ocean Transportation
    • Rail & Intermodal
    • Reverse Logistics
    • Service Parts Management
    • Transportation & Distribution
  • TECHNOLOGY
    • All Technology
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Cloud & On-Demand Systems
    • Data Management (Big Data/IoT/Blockchain)
    • ERP & Enterprise Systems
    • Forecasting & Demand Planning
    • Global Trade Management
    • Inventory Planning/ Optimization
    • Product Lifecycle Management
    • Sales & Operations Planning
    • SC Finance & Revenue Management
    • SC Planning & Optimization
    • Sourcing/Procurement/SRM
    • Supply Chain Visibility
    • Transportation Management
  • GENERAL SCM
    • Business Strategy Alignment
    • Education & Professional Development
    • Global Supply Chain Management
    • Global Trade & Economics
    • HR & Labor Management
    • Quality & Metrics
    • Regulation & Compliance
    • SC Security & Risk Mgmt
    • Sustainability & Corporate Social Responsibility
  • WAREHOUSING
    • All Warehouse Services
    • Conveyors & Sortation
    • Lift Trucks & AGVs
    • Order Fulfillment
    • Packaging
    • RFID, Barcode, Mobility & Voice
    • Robotics
    • Warehouse Management Systems
  • INDUSTRIES
    • Aerospace & Defense
    • Apparel
    • Automotive
    • Chemicals & Energy
    • Consumer Packaged Goods
    • E-Commerce/Omni-Channel
    • Food & Beverage
    • Healthcare
    • High-Tech/Electronics
    • Industrial Manufacturing
    • Pharmaceutical/Biotech
    • Retail
  • REGIONS
    • Asia Pacific
    • Canada
    • China
    • Europe
    • Latin America
    • Middle East/Africa
    • North America
  • THINK TANK
  • PODCASTS
  • VIDEOS
  • WHITEPAPERS
Home » U.S. Celebrates Re-shoring, But Mexico Crashes the Party

U.S. Celebrates Re-shoring, But Mexico Crashes the Party

November 26, 2012
Robert J. Bowman, SupplyChainBrain

On paper, Mexico would seem to offer an attractive balance between low labor cost and proximity to U.S. markets. The latest survey of senior manufacturing executives by AlixPartners finds Mexico the top choice for re-sourcing of production that's fleeing the rising cost and complications of doing business in China. The U.S. garnered 35 percent of the vote, up from 21 percent in a survey taken last year, versus Mexico's hefty 50 percent.

"The U.S., China and Mexico wage differential has shrunk to competitive levels," said Michael Burns, chief commercial officer with Pacer Transportation Solutions, Inc. But let's not repeat the mistake that manufacturers made when they shifted production from the U.S. to China in the first place, and focus solely on labor cost. A number of other factors need to be taken into account. One is the skill level of the resident labor force. Mexico's is relatively high, Burns said during a panel discussion at the annual meeting of the National Industrial Transportation League in Anaheim, Calif. Other potential advantages of producing in Mexico, according to Burns: the position of the peso against the yuan, an intermodal and rail infrastructure that has "vastly improved" over the past decade, and "negligible" supply-chain disruptions arising from security issues. (Maybe. We'll get to that in a minute.)

Bridgestone Corp. is a big believer in Mexico as a place to manufacture for the North American market. In 1980, it opened a facility in Cuernavaca for the making of light-truck and passenger-vehicle tires. Expanded in 2007, the operation now turns out approximately 4,000 tires a day with a workforce of 240, said Dan Vits, general manager of transportation with Bridgestone Americas, Inc.. Between 60 and 70 percent of the plant's production is for the U.S. market.

Bridgestone doubled down on Mexico with the opening in 2007 of a plant in Monterrey. It averages around 8,000 high-performance tires a day, all of which are sold in the U.S.

Why Mexico? Cheap labor, naturally. Between 2003 and the end of 2011, Vits said, the cost of U.S. manufacturing labor increased from $34.50 to $39.32 an hour. During that same period, Mexican labor expense slid from $16.73 to $11.26. And China's rose from $6.90 to $11.83. Now add in the savings incurred by not having to ship finished goods across an ocean, or keep high levels of safety stock in the event of a supply-chain disruption thousands of miles away from end markets, and Mexico becomes an increasingly compelling source of production.

Bridgestone's cost of moving finished product averages $1.49 per mile from Mexican sources versus $1.90 from a port on the U.S. coast, Vits said. Moreover, the company can respond more quickly to changes in market demand, even to the point of supplying original equipment manufacturers and replacement-tire customers on a just-in-time basis.

Then there are the advantages of intermodal transport. Mexico's rail system saw an initial surge of development in double-stack trains some 20 years ago, and a new wave appears to be on the way. Trains generate lower fuel and operating costs than trucks, and experience fewer delays in border crossings and customs clearance, Vits said. In addition, there's an abundance of rail equipment on Mexico routes today, versus some shortages of reliable over-the-road equipment. New hours-of-service regulations imposed by the U.S. Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration have eroded the one advantage that long-haul trucks have over rail: transit time.

Still, Mexico isn't an automatic choice for every company. Despite those factors burnishing the country's image as a global manufacturing paradise, Bridgestone is paying equal if not more attention to the U.S. The parent company is spending $1.2bn on boosting domestic production, including the construction of a plant in South Carolina for the making of tires for the mining industry. Meanwhile, the company's two Mexican operations stay at current levels of activity. Bridgestone hasn't actually shifted any production from China to Mexico since the early 2000s, Vits said.

The U.S. is Bridgestone's focus at the moment because American plants yield higher levels of productivity and quality for the company's OEM customers, according to Vits. "Were seeing less turnover in the U.S. workforce versus the Mexican labor force," he said, noting that Bridgestone is greatly expanding its use of non-union labor.

About that security issue. Mexico has long been a dicey place to move high-value cargo over long distances. Doubts over the safety of trucks are a major reason why the use of intermodal has grown in that country. (Although some of the more aggressive thieves will attack containers or trailers on the rails, even in transit.)

Vits said Mexican carriers offer almost no cargo liability. That's too bad, given the more than 10,000 truck hijackings that occurred in Mexico in 2011, according to Vits, causing an estimated $9bn in unrecovered losses. (More than 84 percent of the incidents took place in transit, he said.) The highest theft rates are in the central and northeastern states. And while intermodal involves less risk, freight is still vulnerable during the drayage portion of the trip. The recent surge of drug-cartel violence in Mexico has only served to make things worse.

"Cargo-security risks must be addressed," said Vits. Burns agreed, detailing some of Pacer's actions in that area: working closely with core providers to vet drivers, operating during certain hours of the day, and even considering police escorts of team drivers on some routes. "You try to manage around the edges," he said.

Clearly there are some major roadblocks to Mexico's attempt to become The Next China for U.S. manufacturers. Don't expect a wholesale migration of plant capacity anytime soon. Maybe companies have learned their lesson about making big sourcing decisions without considering all of the factors at hand.

Next: Two North American contenders for U.S. port business.

Comment on This Article


Keywords: supply chain, supply chain management, manufacturing in Mexico, Mexico supply chain, international trade, inventory control, global logistics, transportation management, logistics management, supply chain planning, retail supply chain, sourcing solutions, supply chain risk management

RELATED CONTENT

RELATED VIDEOS

Logistics Global Logistics Transportation Management Supply Chain Visibility Sourcing/Procurement/SRM SC Planning & Optimization SC Finance & Revenue Management Inventory Planning/ Optimization Global Trade Management SC Security & Risk Mgmt Regulation & Compliance Global Supply Chain Management Business Strategy Alignment Automotive High-Tech/Electronics Industrial Manufacturing Latin America
KEYWORDS Automotive Business Strategy Alignment Global Logistics Global Supply Chain Management Global Trade Management High-Tech/Electronics Industrial Manufacturing international trade inventory control Inventory Planning/ Optimization Latin America Logistics logistics management manufacturing in Mexico Mexico supply chain Regulation & Compliance retail supply chain SC Finance & Revenue Management SC Planning & Optimization SC Security & Risk Mgmt Sourcing Solutions Sourcing/Procurement/SCM supply chain Supply Chain Analysis & Consulting Supply Chain Management Supply Chain Planning Supply Chain Risk Management Supply Chain Visibility Transportation Management
  • Related Articles

    U.S. Celebrates Re-shoring, But Mexico Crashes the Party

    The Re-shoring Debate: Sentiment or Hard Numbers?

    Are Manufacturers Really Re-Shoring?

  • Related Directories

    Kuebix

Robert J. Bowman, SupplyChainBrain

Crafting a New Transportation Bill: The Battle Begins

More from this author

Wake up to Coronavirus Updates and the latest Supply Chain News!

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

Timely, incisive articles delivered directly to your inbox.

Popular Stories

  • Coronavirus-watch-Armada

    Virus Update: J&J Shot Cleared for U.S. Distribution; Microsoft Vows to Fix Vaccination Software

    Coronavirus
  • Mexico

    The Near-Shoring Trend: Will China’s Loss Be Mexico’s Gain?

    Logistics
  • Robotic automation

    Autonomous Supply Chains Are on the Horizon

    Coronavirus
  • Drugmakers

    Research Lays Groundwork for More U.S.-Made Drugs

    Coronavirus
  • Shipping Logjam

    U.S. Retailers See Millions in Sales Delays Amid Shipping Logjam

    Coronavirus

Digital Edition

Scb feb 2021 lg

2021 Supply Chain Management Resource Guide

VIEW THE LATEST ISSUE

Case Studies

  • Remote Implementation: A Dose of the Right Medicine for B2B Pharmacy

  • LSP Saves Customer $1.5 Million a Year With MPO Global Inbound Management

  • Auto Supplier Wows Key Client Using riskmethods Supply Chain Savvy

  • Integrating Shipping and Compliance Saves Conglomerate Millions

  • How a Consumer Goods Giant Upped Its On-Time Delivery Performance

Visit Our Sponsors

6 River Systems ArcBest Armada
aThingz BluJay Burris Logistics
DSC Logistics DCSA (Digital Container Shipping Association) DHL Resilience360
Genpact Geodis GEP
GreyOrange Honeywell Intelligrated Infor
Inmar Kibo Commerce Logility
Magnitude Software MPO Old Dominion
Oliver Wight OpenSky Paccurate
Ports America Purolator QAD Precision
Red Classic Riskmethods Snapfulfil
TGW Systems Transportation Insights Watson Land Company
Westfalia Technologies Workjam Yang Ming
  • More From SCB
    • Featured Content
    • Video Library
    • Think Tank Blog
    • SupplyChainBrain Podcast
    • Whitepapers
    • Webinars
  • Digital Offerings
    • Digital Issue
    • Subscribe
    • Manage Your Subscription
    • Newsletters
  • Resources
    • Events Calendar
    • SCB's Great Supply Chain Partners
    • Supplier Directory
    • Case Study Showcase
    • Supply Chain Innovation Awards
    • 100 Great Partners Form
  • SCB Corporate
    • Advertise on SCB.COM
    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact Us
    • Data Sharing Opt-Out

All content copyright ©2021 Keller International Publishing Corp All rights reserved. No reproduction, transmission or display is permitted without the written permissions of Keller International Publishing Corp

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing